Gino D:

Best XBLA Game: Super Street Fighter II Turbo HD Remix

Runner's Up: Portal: Still Alive, Braid

Comments: Actually, SSF2 not only competes as the best XBLA game this year, but to some degree, it can also stand its ground among other console games for "best fighting game" too!

---

Isaac C:

Best XBLA Game: Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2

Runner's Up: N+, Mega Man 9

Comments: Trying to eliminate the universe of armed and hostile polygons always gives a good natural high. Very healthy.

---

Mabie A:

Best XBLA Game: Portal: still alive

Runner's Up: Duke Nukem 3D

Comments: The Portal XBL port takes the top prize for me on account of it being such a worthwhile swag bag. It's got the original game, new challenges and achievements -- a very good and practical alternative to playing through the entire Orange Box.

---

Chris C:

Best XBLA Game: Braid

Runner's Up: Castle Crashers, Penny Arcade Adventures: On the Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness: Episode Two

Comments: Braid is a game that wears its heart on its sleeve, Jonathan Blow put everything into making this game and it shows, it's fun, innovative, and introspective, few games forge the intimate and personal bond with the gamer that Braid does.